On buying a century-old house, the people who came before us, and knowing that some things are only ours for a little while.
I found our house on Zillow.
After three and a half months of looking for a home in the Columbus area, I came across a listing and immediately told Danny, “We have to buy this house.”
He suggested we fly to Columbus in a few weeks to see it.
A few weeks?
I explained that a house like this, in the neighborhood where I’d grown up, wasn’t going to sit on the market waiting for us. We probably had about 48 hours to make a decision.
Danny, being the reasonable one in our marriage, thought perhaps we should see the house before buying it.
I told him he was welcome to go.
I, on the other hand, had seen everything I needed to see.
The next morning, Danny got on a flight from Chicago to Columbus. He toured the house while I stayed home with Charlotte, and we FaceTimed as he walked through.
He called me afterward and said it was the only house we’d looked at where he could actually picture Charlotte and our future children running up and down the hallway and stairs.
“Let’s talk more about it tonight,” he said.
By the time his plane landed back in Chicago, I’d already had our realtor submit an offer.
“Don’t you think we should have talked about it?” Danny asked.
“I thought we had.”
The House Before Us
One of the things I’ve always loved about old houses is that they come with a history.
Ours was built in 1920 by an architect who designed it for his own family. When we bought the house, we inherited the original blueprints, which we plan to frame and hang once the renovation is complete.
While we’ve spent the past year talking about additions, floor plans, and everything we’d like to change, I’ve also found myself thinking quite a bit about the people who lived here before us.
The family before us called this house home for 42 years.
Forty-two years.
That’s a lot of Christmas mornings, birthdays, dinners, ordinary Tuesdays, and life lived within the same walls.
When we purchased the house, the family was selling it as-is. There wasn’t a beautifully staged listing or a freshly updated kitchen designed to appeal to buyers.
It was a house that had been lived in.
And I loved that about it.
We found little reminders of the family who came before us. A Polaroid. A few cups. A wind chime. The kinds of things that might not mean much to anyone else but make you stop and remember that this was somebody else’s home long before it became yours.
Little pieces of the house's history, left behind for us to discover.
The more time we’ve spent here, the more we’ve learned about the previous owners.
The husband spent his career caring for children as a pediatric hematologist and oncologist. His wife was an educator who went on to become an elementary school principal.
As someone who spent fifteen years working in education, I couldn’t help but appreciate that connection.
And it wasn’t just their professional lives that made an impression.
Our neighbors have shared stories about the family. Even a woman at the water department recognized our address when we were setting up our utilities and immediately had wonderful things to say about them.
It’s a funny thing, buying a house from people you’ve never met and slowly getting to know them through everyone else.
But the more we heard, the more it felt like we’d bought a home that had been genuinely loved.
Good Juju
I’ve said from the beginning that this house has good juju.
Not because everything works. It most certainly does not.
We’ve inherited plenty of projects, questionable decisions made over the decades, and appliances that have lived exceptionally long lives.
Our stove is older than I am, weighs approximately as much as a small automobile, and includes the microwave, oven, and stovetop in one enormous unit. I'm fairly certain removing it will require a team of professionals and possibly a structural engineer.
Meet Stella. She's been holding down the kitchen for decades, and while I appreciate her dedication, I think she's earned her retirement.
But there’s something reassuring about knowing that good people lived a good life here.
They raised their two boys here. They built careers, celebrated milestones, hosted holidays, and went about the ordinary business of living.
And now it’s our turn.
When we wrote our offer letter, we talked about coming back to Columbus after thirteen years in Chicago. About Charlotte, who was two at the time, and the baby we were expecting. About wanting to raise our family close to the people and places that had shaped my own childhood.
We pictured little feet running down the stairs, a swing set in the backyard, and dinners around the table.
All the things that make a house a home.
We were imagining our future in a place that already held so much of somebody else’s past.
Making It Ours Without Erasing What Was
As we’ve planned our renovation, I’ve thought a lot about what it means to own an old house.
We are making significant changes. There’s no getting around that.
We’re adding space, reworking rooms, and updating systems that have needed attention for a very long time.
And yes, having appliances from this millennium would be nice, too.
But we’ve never wanted to turn this house into something it isn’t.
It’s a Georgian. It’s been standing here for more than a century. And while our family needs it to function differently than it did for the people who lived here before us, we want to respect what makes it special.
That means thinking carefully about the architecture, preserving the character where we can, and making choices that will still feel appropriate years from now.
Not because we’re trying to create a museum.
Quite the opposite.
We want a house where our kids can run through the hallways, where people feel comfortable putting their feet up, and where everyday life happens without worrying about keeping everything perfect.
We want to give this old house another full, happy chapter.
Some things about this old house never needed changing.
Just the Stewards
I’ve been talking about writing this story for a while.
And then, earlier this week, our next-door neighbor told me that the woman who lived here before us had passed away.
I don't know what to make of the timing. Maybe it was just coincidence. But it felt like a little God wink.
Here we were, already reflecting on the history of this house and the people who lived here before us, when we learned that one of those people had died.
I never had the chance to meet her. I wish I had.
But I’m grateful for the stories we’ve heard, for the little pieces of the family’s life that were left behind, and for the opportunity to care for a place that meant so much to them.
I sometimes wonder what the previous family would think if they could see the plans spread across our dining room table.
They might be surprised by a few of our decisions.
They’d probably be delighted to know that the house will once again be filled with little children running through the hallways.
Or at least I hope so.
Because the more time we spend here, the more I realize that owning an old house isn’t really about being the person who gets to have it forever.
It’s about taking care of it while it’s yours.
The family before us had their chapter.
Now we’re writing ours.
And someday, hopefully a very long time from now, another family will walk through these rooms and begin imagining their own life here.
For now, we’re just the stewards.